diff --git a/app/SmartAlbums/OnThisDayAlbum.php b/app/SmartAlbums/OnThisDayAlbum.php
index 21e9032be1b..f077739be78 100644
--- a/app/SmartAlbums/OnThisDayAlbum.php
+++ b/app/SmartAlbums/OnThisDayAlbum.php
@@ -35,6 +35,7 @@ function (Builder $query) use ($today) {
 					->whereDay('photos.taken_at', '=', $today->day))
 				->orWhere(fn (Builder $q) => $q
 					->whereNull('photos.taken_at')
+					->whereYear('photos.created_at', '<', $today->year)
 					->whereMonth('photos.created_at', '=', $today->month)
 					->whereDay('photos.created_at', '=', $today->day));
 			}