-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 403
New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
Collision logging, Transformers for JSON and Standard Files #962
base: main
Are you sure you want to change the base?
Collision logging, Transformers for JSON and Standard Files #962
Conversation
Sorry for the delay. Can you rebase again? I changed a lot on the main... |
d19c391
to
2bf56ae
Compare
Did the rebase. |
if (!shadow.isAllowModuleInfos()) { | ||
excludes.add(MODULE_INFO_CLASS) | ||
} |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Choose a reason for hiding this comment
The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.
I see so many changes are addressed in this PR, supporting including module-info.class
is one of them, right? Can we extract this point as a separated PR?
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Choose a reason for hiding this comment
The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.
Well, the problem is: Including the module-info.class
isn't directly a problem. While it's non-intuitive to include it, it's already possible.
The real problem comes into play if you unknowingly add a dependency which contains also a module-info.class
. Meaning: You have a very, really problematic file collision. Which is what this patch is about.
So I added a listing, to inform about the module-info.class
s content. But only if the user wants to include it. Because in the default settings, the module-info is excluded anyway.
And after much exploration I gave up, and have to admit that johnrengelman was completely right in #710: The only clean way allow the module-info, is with an extra option.
But I already thought: Maybe I should only list the module-info's content if there is a file collision? On the other hand: That file is so important if included, I decided to list it always.
Used "npm audit fix".
…rite an existing resource
…r to merge standard files
…rite an existing resource
…r to merge standard files
…o debug So the user doesn't get flooded with superfluous logs
…e-info.class files easily
41e8186
to
dba0157
Compare
This is the PR #773, but on a new, rebased branch (the original PR was made 2 years ago).
Hi, I fitted the collsion_logging merge request from chapmajs to your current source code (#126).
Also I followed your wish to use typed parameters (which was really needed, because after adding them, some problems became obvious).
After that I used the modified plugin and with the warnings I could fix my problems instantly. Great!
The only problem was, that I was flooded with warnings about colliding META-INF/NOTICE, META-INF/license.txt, readme.txt and similar files. So I added a transformer, StandardFilesMergeTransformer, which takes these standard files, which exist in all big projects in big numbers, and merges them.
Since these are all pretty primitive files regarding their structure, no special YAML or JSON files, I just concatenate their contents the following way:
The StandardFilesMergeTransformer transformer is added as default. It can be removed with "removeDefaultTransformers".
I added it as default because otherwise:
like "META-INF/notice.txt", "META-INF/license.txt"...
Added JsonTransformer for JSON files, based on JsonTransformer from @LogicFan. Their code is also under Apache License 2. Extended it, so it can be applied to multiple files.
Lowered the logging level for colliding META-INF/MANIFEST.MF files, from warning to debug, so the user doesn't get flooded with unimportant messages.
In discussion Shadow Jar for modular project with module-info #710 it came to light that some people need the original
module-info.class
not to be removed, which is also a possible source for file collision problems. While it's hard to find a nice, quick solution for that, I at least added an option to include the module-info files and list their contents (listing appears only ifmodule-info.class
's aren't excluded).The option is:
allowModuleInfos()
, and used in action indef 'Tests the info about the module-info.class, if removed from standard excludes'()
.With that changes, any user should be capable to build a fat JAR with more than one Spring (Boot) dependency, right out of the box. Otherwise it's a real pain to find out which files collide, and how to merge colliding JSON files, since that is the only colliding file type, which misses a merging transformer from this plugin.
And JSON is very common!