No sound after wake after a while

[Luka020]

Hi Ab2774,

After a wake period or black screen period (just before sleep) the sound stops working when i use Siri afterwards.
After i have used Siri and i did this after a wake the sound disappears after 30 seconds to 1 minute.

Steps to recreate

• Watch a Youtube video for example.
• Let the laptop fall a sleep. In the settings app under power management you can set this to 1 minute for this purpose.
• After wake use Siri (ask to put the volume louder or lower as an example)
• Continue the Youtube video and after about a minute the sound wil stop working.

To get the sound back you have to ask siri something again or close the lid of the laptop and it wil be back for a little while again and then it will stop working again, until you restart the computer.

Hope you know what's going on better than i do.

What i also tried unfortunately all with the same result which is no sound after wake.

• Changed layout-id form 20 to 13
• Turned off both "AFGLowpowerstate" and "ResetHDA"
• Turned off only "AFGLowpowerstate" and left ResetHDA on and visa versa.

[Ab2774]

Hi
That's a known issue with ALC230 with both layouts 13 and 20
a few hours ago (surprisingly) @ameenjuz created a pull request to fix that issue acidanthera/AppleALC#541 with the layout 20, I haven't tested it, I'm gonna test it later and if it's confirmed working I'll create another pull request for the layout 13.
Previously, I fixed the mute button with both layouts 13 and 20, which was a bummer.
I'm gonna test later and confirm it.
Cheers

[Luka020]

Nice!

[Ab2774]

Hi
I've tested it now and the problem still exists, I'm gonna try multiple solutions in the next few days starting with adding new Config Data, but for now, the easiest solution I've found is to plug your headphones and unplug it, this is a "temporary" fix for now.
for now, you report this issue to Acidanthera Bugtracker.
Cheers

[ameenjuz]

I closed the lid of the laptop then opened lid the headphone didn't work with Siri
once again I put this value into wakeconfigdata 01970725 02170883 solved the problem
make sure you are using ALC230 Layout id 20
sorry for my weak English I hope that you will understand
put this 01970725 02170883 into wakeconfigdata I hope will solve

[Ab2774]

Hi
I appreciate your hard work @ameenjuz and your WakeConifgData is almost working except, the problem still exists, before, after sleep, the sound may come and may not, but now, it will disappear for a few seconds (5-15s) and it will surely come back, which is good news and huge progress, I'm gonna try to add more to WakeConifgData and maybe change the ConfigData itself.
Grateful for your help.
@Luka020 you can use this almost fixed ( as I explained above) kext till we figure something out
Thanks.
AppleALC.kext.zip

[Luka020]

Thank you guys for your work! I appreciate it, unfortunately i still get the same problem tough.
My internal speakers stop working after wake from sleep, only way to reactivate is when i call siri or close and open the lid.

I did not test it with headphones because i do not use them.

This is only temporally, because after i opened the lid the sound does come back but it disappears again after 5 seconds or so. and then i have to repeat the process.

It will be fixed interesting to see!

[ameenjuz]

guys I don't know why do you have not work
I have working fine everything ( speaker headphone line in ) sleep wake also I don't seem any issue
double check your Config.plist and DSDT&SSDT related to audio

[Ab2774]

Hi,
There are two explanations for this:

1. That we (me and @Luka020) have a faulty battery, which effects the trackpad and makes it so weird and slippery to use, and makes the whole system lags when plugging and unplugging the power source, it may affect the mic after sleep but has not been confirmed yet (needs someone to test it on Windows).
2. Uncompleted kext (ConfigData and WakeConifgData) which I'm trying to add a new layout with new ConfigData, am gonna test and if it worked I'm gonna create a pull request, wish me luck.

[Luka020]

Hi Ab2774,

I think it's the second explanation. As for the first one my battery works okey and i do not experience any issues regarding trackpad and plugging and unplugging the power source, same goes for the trackpad.

It's good to know that when my battery dies those are the kind of issues i can look forward to.

Good luck man, hope you find out the issue!

[Ab2774]

Update: I've tried lots of things but still no luck fixing it, I even tried the original CodecDump from Linux but still...
@ameenjuz I'm sure that you have this issue too, it's not about sleep to be precise, it's about power when waking from sleep while the power source is connected and then unplugging it, the sound disappears, same if you used the mic after sleep.
I'm gonna report this issue to Acidanthera Bugtracker and wish that someone will help us to fix this issue.

[ameenjuz]

@Ab2774 i tested i have no such issue
sleep with power source after wake unplugging it no issue
double check your configuration config and dsdt and ssdts
01970725 02170883 into wakeconfigdata

[Luka020]

@ameenjuz i like to test it to could i do it with your current SSDT's upload ?

[Ab2774]

@Ab2774 i tested i have no such issue
sleep with power source after wake unplugging it no issue
double check your configuration config and dsdt and ssdts
01970725 02170883 into wakeconfigdata

Hi, I think our audio codec needs to be injected by SSDT (haven't tested it yet).
I'm gonna try this solution now then tell you the results.
Also, can you please add 01970725 02170883 WakeConfigData to both layouts 13 & 20 in your pull request.
Cheers.

[ameenjuz]

@Luka020 @Ab2774
I have two partition Catalina installed 1 with OpenCore 2 with Clover bootliader
1 i m using OpenCore with full DSDT patch Alc230 layout id 20 but layout 13 didn'work well my machine
2 also using clover bootloader with Full Acpi Hotpatch SSDTs Alc230 layout id 20
I will attach my EFI folder soon

[Ab2774]

Hi @ameenjuz thanks for your hard work.
I installed MacOS on this laptop since 2018, till now, I haven’t figure out a way to fix this issue, I tried so much but still, so if you can tell us how did fixed it I would really appreciate it.
Also, I was planning to release v1.1.1 update with some minor fixes and improvements last week but because of this issue, I’m gonna delay it to 1st May till we fix this issue, if we couldn’t, I’m gonna release the update anyway.
Cheers

[ameenjuz]

this is my full OpenCore-EFI Folder
full dsdt patched
test it if you have same my laptop Lenovo Ideapad 320-14ikb
OpenCore-EFI.zip

[Luka020]

@ameenjuz I tried the Opencore-EFI but got the same results. i made a video with the issue.

• What i did was set the power settings to 1 minute so that i would go to sleep.
• When in sleep i woke the laptop up.
• Then i played a video and turned on Siri. and after a while 30 seconds the sound disappears to reactivate the sound i have to turn on Siri again and than it will repeat the cycle until i restart.

Hope this helps

Sound Issue Ideapad 320 14IKB.mp4.zip

[ameenjuz]

@Ab2774 Did you boot with my dsdt?

[Ab2774]

@Ab2774 Did you boot with my dsdt?

Hi,
Yes I booted from your EFI and unfortunately the issue still exists, I remember that someone had this issue before and fixed it by editing the ConfigData, I’m gonna try the same thing and see.
Thanks

[Ab2774]

Hi @ameenjuz,
Great work what you did in your EFI OpenCore, I'm wondering if you have the same OpenCore EFI but with SSDTs, because DSDTs aren't customizable at all, I got most of the thing working but there are still some missing things.
Thanks for your help.
Cheers

[ameenjuz]

@Ab2774
what is missing
this is full patched customized DSDT
patched
GFX0
PMCR
PNLF
USBX
EC
IGPU
SATA
SMBUS
HPET
USB MAPED UNDER DSDT
I2C CRS
RMCF
Q11 Q12
GPRW for Instant wake
MCHC
OSI
PPMC
HECI
i couldn't describe all patched because english is not my native language
this dsdt booting fine with windows 10 and macOS Catalina including If (_OSI ("Darwin"))
no need ssdts and ACPI renaming patch
this DSDT work fully

[Ab2774]

@Ab2774

what is missing

this is full patched customized DSDT

patched

GFX0

PMCR

PNLF

USBX

EC

IGPU

SATA

SMBUS

HPET

USB MAPED UNDER DSDT

I2C CRS

RMCF

Q11 Q12

GPRW for Instant wake

MCHC

OSI

PPMC

HECI

i couldn't describe all patched because english is not my native language

this dsdt booting fine with windows 10 and macOS Catalina including If (_OSI ("Darwin"))

no need ssdts and ACPI renaming patch

this DSDT work fully

Hi @ameenjuz
Thanks for fast response, really appreciate it,
What I mean by some missing things is that “DMAC, EC rename, ALS0” and more are not included in your DSDT, now I know these are optional things and not really important to have but they really improve the experience, I managed to get almost everything working in OpenCore before but two things I couldn’t: trackpad and battery, trackpad is almost working except it’s working in Polling mode not GPIO mode and the reason is rename _CRS to _XCRS causes kernel panic in OpenCore, if you have any idea for how’s can this problem can be solved I would really appreciate it.
Cheers

[Ab2774]

By the way, there are some missing things for trackpad in your DSDT as shown in the photos from GenI2C, usually, VoodooI2C Prevent Apple I2C kexts from attaching to I2C controllers automatically, but in OpenCore you have to do it manually.

Before:

After:

Enable these in config.plist:

And don't update VoodooI2C to the latest 2.4.2 because there are some bugs with it.
Cheers
DSDT.aml.zip

[ameenjuz]

@Ab2774
my dear No need Prevent Apple I2c controller patch it is already added VoodooI2C.kext/Contents/Info OSBundledRequied=Root by Alexander
i also will provide you now ACPI Clover Hotpatch SSDTs
now aday i m focus at OpenCore

Clover-EFI.zip

[Ab2774]

Hi @Luka020,
so sorry for the late response, but in the main time, I'm working on some improvement for the EFI Clover and I'm gonna add OpenCore bootloader in the next update, there's no new news about the sound issue, I tried lots of things but I can't figure out what's causing this issue, nowadays, I'm more focusing on fixing some little bugs in OpenCore bootloader, I was planning to release a new update today but in the new Clover update 5115 fixed the theme issue but it can't boot, so I'm gonna wait a bit more till they fix this issue, and Acidanthera gonna drop an update for their kexts in the next few days, so I'm gonna release the update soon then retry working on the kext.
Regards

[Luka020]

Hi @Luka020,
so sorry for the late response, but in the main time, I'm working on some improvement for the EFI Clover and I'm gonna add OpenCore bootloader in the next update, there's no new news about the sound issue, I tried lots of things but I can't figure out what's causing this issue, nowadays, I'm more focusing on fixing some little bugs in OpenCore bootloader, I was planning to release a new update today but in the new Clover update 5115 fixed the theme issue but it can't boot, so I'm gonna wait a bit more till they fix this issue, and Acidanthera gonna drop an update for their kexts in the next few days, so I'm gonna release the update soon then retry working on the kext.
Regards

No worries bro, i appriciate your responds. You are doing a great job and made my hackintosh to what it is now, i can not ask for more!

[ameenjuz]

@Ab2774 please provide me your EFI folder and config

[Ab2774]

Hi @ameenjuz,
yeah, sure, you didn't mention which one so I uploaded them both.
Current status in OpenCore:
Neither PWRB nor wake with the screen are working, unlike Clover, OpenCore doesn't patch the power button automatically, I guess I'm gonna wait for the next release and see, neither my EFI nor yours have PWRB appears in IOREG, pressing the power button for 5 seconds normally shows this window:

but in this situation, it restarts immediately, here's a comparison for an IOREG copy I took from Clover and one from OpenCore:


as you can see it's recognized by the system but it's not working, when waking from sleep, you have to press any key to light up the screen, and this also is patched automatically by Clover, I'm gonna try to fix these issues and then release it in the final update soon.
Current status in Clover: it all working just fine but with the last update, it doesn't boot up, so I'm gonna wait till they release the 5116 version.
Regards
EFI OpenCore.zip
EFI Clover.zip

[ameenjuz]

@Ab2774
Put darkwake=1 in boot- arg in opencore's config
put to sleep and press power button will work

[Ab2774]

@Ab2774

Put darkwake=1 in boot- arg in opencore's config

put to sleep and press power button will work

Hi,
This actually fixed the Lid is issue, so SSDT-EXT4-WakeScreen is no longer needed, but the power button problem is still exists, I’m gonna try multiple solutions and see.
Cheers

[Ab2774]

Hi @Luka020
I’ll install Linux in the next few days to get a fresh-new Codec Dump, to rewrite the ConfigData, and for layout 13 (IdeaPad 310 with no Line In) I’m gonna rewrite it too, Wish me luck.
Regards

[Luka020]

Hi Ab2774,

Wish you all the luck man! Hope you can do it!

[Ab2774]

Hi @Luka020, there's some good news, while I was searching for a solution to this issue, I found a guide made by @fewtarius that may fix this hideous issue, I followed his guide and now ALCPlugFix isn't required any more! I'm trying to contact him to help me.
Wish me luck!